ATI or Nvidia?

hi mga master get ko ulit advise nyo..
my purpose: for CG rendering and anim., multi tasking)

my choices:
Nvidia GTX 275 896MB DDR3 448bit HDMI
or
ATI Powercolor HD5770 1GB DDR5 HDMI

which po is better?although mas mahal ng konti ung GTX, pero pasok parin sa budget.. nsa 10k kasi budget..

pakonti konti ng nabubuo ang CPU na inaasemble ko, (thanks to CGpinoy mas namura pero mas gumanda ang specs)
as of now nkaorder na:
intel core i7 930
Asus extreme motherboard (hindi ung rampage)
8 GB Ram
1t western HDD
1000w corsair power supply
optical drive
cooler fan

kaso wala pa casing at video card,
pero may choice na ng casing..

thanks and Godbless

Nvidia all the way...

Usually intel-nvidia, amd-powercolor

Dito lang ako nahirapan intendihin ang difference ng ddr3 at ddr5. Di ko din alam kung gaano kalaki ang difference sa performance. Pro alam ko malakas na ang GTX na yan. Yan ang gusto kong upgrade.

i like nvidia based graphic card for the reason na mas marami ako na encountered na problem sa ATI. personal opinion lang naman.

jheteg wrote:i like nvidia based graphic card for the reason na mas marami ako na encountered na problem sa ATI. personal opinion lang naman.

---nampata pakapata... tama ka dyan ser sakit ng ulo yang ATI personal opinion din... I never had problems with Nvidia cards, naka tatlo din ata ako, but with ATI dito sa laptop ku susme ATI2DVAG INFINITE LOOP BLUESCREEN OF DEATH... not to mention parang ang trend eh towards gpu based rendering engines (CUDA, tama ba?)... and I think Nvidia is one step ahead na with regards to this... mas maganda na ang prepared...

ive used to have Nvidia cards from the Titanium to overhype fx's to my overprice EVGA signature 7900Gt

but since i looked for a cheaper alternative, i've try Ati HD3870 series to HD4890 Toxic, now im using HD5770 Toxic (pansamantagal), i never looked back and looking ahead for another red card on my list.

@kieko
Nvidia 275 = raw power this card wins vs. 5770, direct competitior is Ati HD4870, but can only run Dx10, if youre still using windowsXP, this will be your card.. Cuda and PhysX, dont mind this because you will not touch this at all..

Ati5770 = if you're using Win7 already which support Dx11 and Eye Infinity if you will be using 3 or more monitors in the near future... Sapphire makes the best brand for Ati.

which card is ahead with the tech (futureproof)... the card with DX11 wins.

cloud20 wrote:Nvidia all the way...

bokkins wrote:Usually intel-nvidia, amd-powercolor

Dito lang ako nahirapan intendihin ang difference ng ddr3 at ddr5. Di ko din alam kung gaano kalaki ang difference sa performance. Pro alam ko malakas na ang GTX na yan. Yan ang gusto kong upgrade.

jheteg wrote:i like nvidia based graphic card for the reason na mas marami ako na encountered na problem sa ATI. personal opinion lang naman.

cloud20 wrote:

jheteg wrote:i like nvidia based graphic card for the reason na mas marami ako na encountered na problem sa ATI. personal opinion lang naman.

---nampata pakapata... tama ka dyan ser sakit ng ulo yang ATI personal opinion din... I never had problems with Nvidia cards, naka tatlo din ata ako, but with ATI dito sa laptop ku susme ATI2DVAG INFINITE LOOP BLUESCREEN OF DEATH... not to mention parang ang trend eh towards gpu based rendering engines (CUDA, tama ba?)... and I think Nvidia is one step ahead na with regards to this... mas maganda na ang prepared...

salamat sa mga advise masters..
i think ill go for nvidia since its much more recommended and according to my research, ATI is more on games..
Godbless

dpyxl wrote:ive used to have Nvidia cards from the Titanium to overhype fx's to my overprice EVGA signature 7900Gt

but since i looked for a cheaper alternative, i've try Ati HD3870 series to HD4890 Toxic, now im using HD5770 Toxic (pansamantagal), i never looked back and looking ahead for another red card on my list.

@kieko
Nvidia 275 = raw power this card wins vs. 5770, direct competitior is Ati HD4870, but can only run Dx10, if youre still using windowsXP, this will be your card.. Cuda and PhysX, dont mind this because you will not touch this at all..

Ati5770 = if you're using Win7 already which support Dx11 and Eye Infinity if you will be using 3 or more monitors in the near future... Sapphire makes the best brand for Ati.

which card is ahead with the tech (futureproof)... the card with DX11 wins.

thanks for this infor sir,
i have research the difference of dx10 and dx11, i think its more on the quality of the video, but since you said GTX 275 is raw power which i think i'll be needing, i think i will go with nvidia cards...the only problem is the limited stocks..hehe..

thanks ulit sir this are very important..

bokkins wrote:Usually intel-nvidia, amd-powercolor

Dito lang ako nahirapan intendihin ang difference ng ddr3 at ddr5. Di ko din alam kung gaano kalaki ang difference sa performance. Pro alam ko malakas na ang GTX na yan. Yan ang gusto kong upgrade.

sana makatulong itong nabasa ko sir from a website forum regarding ddr3 and ddr5


http://forums.whirlpool.net.au/forum-replies-archive.cfm/1114666.html

ATI ako. 10/10 para sakin.

Thanks sa info bro. Alam ko na ang difference this time.

At may natutunan akong bago. Actually, nacuento na sa akin to ng kaibigan ko. Get 1 card now. Tapos pag may extra ka pa soon, kuha ka ulit ng isa pa. Haha! I think supported naman ng motherboard mo ang crossfire. 2 video cards, awesome power!

ati lalo na crossfire.

for ati experienced users, may i ask how ati cards perform using acad, 3dmax, skup, rhino, or any other cg softwares that involves 3d modeling?

on this part i'm really lost, on which brand has a better hand on 3d application other than games and videos.

i have clarification,

do we really need dx11? in our cg works.

bicolano wrote:i have clarification,

do we really need dx11? in our cg works.

I think kasama yan sa progress bro. May not now, Pro baka pagng-release ang 3d softwares that would require that. Usually ganun naman talaga nangyayari. Kaya din umabot na sa dx11 yan.

thanks bokkins!
kasi im planning to doubled my GTX 295, kaya lang my 295 doesn't support dx11. but i think mas gagaan ang viewport if i go for quad-sli. yun nga lang hindi future proof ung upgrade. quiet confuse

bicolano wrote:thanks bokkins!
kasi im planning to doubled my GTX 295, kaya lang my 295 doesn't support dx11. but i think mas gagaan ang viewport if i go for quad-sli. yun nga lang hindi future proof ung upgrade. quiet confuse

Alam ko naman ikaw, eh pag nag-upgrade ka, halimaw ang specs. I think magagamit mo pa din naman yan for a year or 2 without worrying about dx11.

So basically, laspagin mo muna yan 2 gpu's mo. Saka major upgrade, by then, bawing bawi na yang existing PC mo.

bokkins wrote:Thanks sa info bro. Alam ko na ang difference this time.

At may natutunan akong bago. Actually, nacuento na sa akin to ng kaibigan ko. Get 1 card now. Tapos pag may extra ka pa soon, kuha ka ulit ng isa pa. Haha! I think supported naman ng motherboard mo ang crossfire. 2 video cards, awesome power!

thank sir..
tinitignan ko pa kasi availability ng stock..ang bilis maubos ng gtx...
wow..crossfire is a good idea..hehe..

Actually these graphic cards are alright to buy. The more powerful, the more expensive... it's all OK! Kasi gpu rendering is the next big thing in our industry! Ayus ba!

ronski_g wrote:Actually these graphic cards are alright to buy. The more powerful, the more expensive... it's all OK! Kasi gpu rendering is the next big thing in our industry! Ayus ba!

thanks sir..



thanks fpor your advise..
i had bought nvidia GTX 465, ung dual fan..supported nito and Dx11

may i ask you sir kieko how much the difference in price between gtx 275 and gtx 295?

I already tried both, but I would still prefer NVIDIA.

andro111985 wrote:may i ask you sir kieko how much the difference in price between gtx 275 and gtx 295?

i have no idea of the of the gtx 295 sir but the 275 it cost less than 11k here in the Philippines...

but a friend told me if bibili na din sir, dun sa mga latest sir which is GTX 4series, kaya nga 465 na kinuha ko..

necrolyte wrote:I already tried both, but I would still prefer NVIDIA.

sir necrolyte salamat ulit sa mga konting info na binigay nyo naka save ako ng medyo malaki..

@kieko

hehehe... walang anuman yun bro.