Are Renderings Bad for Architecture?

What do you think guys?

http://www.archdaily.com/383325/are-renderings-bad-for-architecture/?source=internal&medium=widget&content=383325

nice article and nice comments below the article

maybe it's like this

at school skills =better presentation= higher grades =happy

at real practice skills =better presentation= ROI = happy

CE ako

ito lang masasabi ko naganda ang rendering kaso yung mga archi focus na sila sa render.. nawawala na yung design
opinion lang mga sir

kasi napupunta sa CE yung design. hehe.. joke lang sir zagvot..

zagvot wrote:CE ako

ito lang masasabi ko naganda ang rendering kaso yung mga archi focus na sila sa render.. nawawala na yung design
opinion lang mga sir

sure po kayo?

virus wrote:kasi napupunta sa CE yung design. hehe.. joke lang sir zagvot..

hihi.

basta relax lang tayo mga masters....baka san nanaman mapunta to

pro archi ako wala akong issue diyan kaso diba maganda yung laman ng article

(causing students to spend hours perfecting visuals instead of perfecting the design)
ang maganda dito is madali ma benta yung project mo

Try nga natin gumawa ng design then walang perspective render.
Ano kaya masasabi ng client.

Hindi mo rin masasabi sir na fous nlng kami sa rendering. Hindi mo rin alam kung gaano sumasakit ulo namin sa paggawa ng conceptual, space planning etc. bago kami makabuo ng itsura ng bldg..Base kasi sa na experience ko may CE akong ka kompitensya sa gagawing project.. Marunong syang magrender ganda nga ng render eh.. Pero ako sketch lang na perspective ang ginawa ko.. Pero at the end ako pinili ni client, why? Kasi nga maganda yung prinisent nya sa client pero super sablay sa space planning.. Pano pa kaya kung marunong pa akong magrender that time..

theomatheus wrote:Hindi mo rin masasabi sir na fous nlng kami sa rendering. Hindi mo rin alam kung gaano sumasakit ulo namin sa paggawa ng conceptual, space planning etc. bago kami makabuo ng itsura ng bldg..Base kasi sa na experience ko may CE akong ka kompitensya sa gagawing project.. Marunong syang magrender ganda nga ng render eh.. Pero ako sketch lang na perspective ang ginawa ko.. Pero at the end ako pinili ni client, why? Kasi nga maganda yung prinisent nya sa client pero super sablay sa space planning.. Pano pa kaya kung marunong pa akong magrender that time..

+1 like

may pros and cons talaga mga sir

mas maganda talaga na archi ang gumawa

theomatheus wrote:Hindi mo rin masasabi sir na fous nlng kami sa rendering. Hindi mo rin alam kung gaano sumasakit ulo namin sa paggawa ng conceptual, space planning etc. bago kami makabuo ng itsura ng bldg..Base kasi sa na experience ko may CE akong ka kompitensya sa gagawing project.. Marunong syang magrender ganda nga ng render eh.. Pero ako sketch lang na perspective ang ginawa ko.. Pero at the end ako pinili ni client, why? Kasi nga maganda yung prinisent nya sa client pero super sablay sa space planning.. Pano pa kaya kung marunong pa akong magrender that time..

very well said Sir

zagvot wrote:may pros and cons talaga mga sir

mas maganda talaga na archi ang gumawa

Magkakasundo tayo dyan sir... Magpapastructural na ako sayo

theomatheus wrote:

zagvot wrote:may pros and cons talaga mga sir

mas maganda talaga na archi ang gumawa

Magkakasundo tayo dyan sir... Magpapastructural na ako sayo

naku sir baguhan lang ako ehehe
maganda kasi kapag team-up masaya yung project

naku sir baguhan lang ako ehehe
maganda kasi kapag team-up masaya yung project [/quote]

Sana Sir ganyan din sila magisip yung mga ibang CE.

o_yap1003 wrote:naku sir baguhan lang ako ehehe
maganda kasi kapag team-up masaya yung project

Sana Sir ganyan din sila magisip yung mga ibang CE.
[/quote]

archi graduate kasi kapatid ko hopefully makapasa sa exam
kaya alam ko gaano kahirap maging archi
at saka di ko yan field eh ehehe

pero tumatambay ako dito para makipag-brain storm ehehe

zagvot wrote:may pros and cons talaga mga sir

mas maganda talaga na archi ang gumawa

-- Its not "mas maganda talaga na archi ang gumawa".. TALAGANG DAPAT ARCHITECT ANG GUMAWA.

cloud20 wrote:

zagvot wrote:may pros and cons talaga mga sir

mas maganda talaga na archi ang gumawa

-- Its not "mas maganda talaga na archi ang gumawa".. TALAGANG DAPAT ARCHITECT ANG GUMAWA.

wahihi

Are they bad? Hell no!

theomatheus wrote:Hindi mo rin masasabi sir na fous nlng kami sa rendering. Hindi mo rin alam kung gaano sumasakit ulo namin sa paggawa ng conceptual, space planning etc. bago kami makabuo ng itsura ng bldg..Base kasi sa na experience ko may CE akong ka kompitensya sa gagawing project.. Marunong syang magrender ganda nga ng render eh.. Pero ako sketch lang na perspective ang ginawa ko.. Pero at the end ako pinili ni client, why? Kasi nga maganda yung prinisent nya sa client pero super sablay sa space planning.. Pano pa kaya kung marunong pa akong magrender that time..

Like na like po....

cloud20 wrote:

zagvot wrote:may pros and cons talaga mga sir

mas maganda talaga na archi ang gumawa

-- Its not "mas maganda talaga na archi ang gumawa".. TALAGANG DAPAT ARCHITECT ANG GUMAWA.

direct hit. agree with this. Architects should provide architectural materials including the presentation (kung architectural ang focus)

rendering are only for visualizations, architecture not necessarily, architecture the way we do here in our office in HK is very different in philippines.
a mere sketch by pencil is enough for to give an architecture message.
architecture can exist without vray or 3ds max or other softwares. real architecture may not be the real architecture you know. think about this, look around in philippines, is there an architecture?

ciaoriki wrote:rendering are only for visualizations, architecture not necessarily, architecture the way we do here in our office in HK is very different in philippines.
a mere sketch by pencil is enough for to give an architecture message.
architecture can exist without vray or 3ds max or other softwares. real architecture may not be the real architecture you know. think about this, look around in philippines, is there an architecture?

nice one ehehe

@ ciaoriki agree ako sa mga sinabi nyo.pero question lang po. bigyan mo naman kami ng idea about sa sinasabi mo sa architecture sa office nyo sa HK and dito sa pinas..??

galing me sa mideast dati, 5yrs me dun, archl office din, dito hk 8 yrs na me.
comparing sa practice ng architecure sa pinas and comparing especially here, medyo malayong malayo. sa conceptual ideas medyo mas malaki ang definition, at binibigyan ng pansin ng husto ang HKIA ang practicer at profession, madalas ang
architectural design competition dito, and na-ininvolve pati mga architectural students.in that way nabibigyan sila ng boses. na kamakailan i think two yrs ago may design competition dito somewhere in kowloon, among competitors tatlo ang naiwan for final selection, which are fosters and partners, OMA (by koolhas, and one local which is rocco design, the public was involved in the selection, they were allowed to make crirticism and opinion, in the end foster was selected, i think architecture in pinas should get also the voice of the people, their opinions and concern. lalo na kung public ang makikinabang sa infrastructure. sa atin sa pinas pag sinabi na ganito, ay ganun na lang. architecture practice should be tied to socio. hindi lang sa zoning, setbacks, and other techincal stuff and legal stuff concerning design. pre if you dont mind try comapring pinas with other asian neighbors, whre do you put ours?
structures greatly affect a locales projection, structures affects mans movement, behaviour and experience. architecture to guard man against the elements is an old definition of architecture, architecure today should give man an experience to make oneself be called a human being. sa mga architects sa pinas, am actually also one, dapat siguro we should look at architecture with meaning, kung merong 2d plans, then 3d visualizations, dapt siguro masundan ng 4d experience. when you watch a 3d film, what do you feel, i think thats how architecture sould be.

and kung hindi nyo natatanong ang name ng dating office namin ay OMA HK,
rem koolhas setup ng office dito sa hk with the name OMA ASIA, as a base
ng mge projects nya sa china. ang office namin ang gumawa ng
south korean telecom building, won from a competition. have a look at the design, and you will know what i mean.